Story Mode:Episode 6: A Portal to Mystery
The new Order of the Stone (consisting of Jesse, Lukas, Petra, and Ivor) find one of the portals leading them to a cemetery. There, they discover a book on a tombstone, which is an invitation to a mansion owned by the Host. As they read, they are surrounded by zombies but manage to escape and make it to the mansion.
Upon arrival, the front door is locked, so the group enters through a kitchen window. Inside, they meet YouTubers TorqueDawg and CaptainSparklez. Suddenly, TorqueDawg is killed by tipped arrows shot from a dispenser. LDShadowLady then greets the group, and they all head to the main hall. There, they meet Cassie Rose (with her pet cat, Winslow), DanTDM, Stampy Cat, and stacyplays, and then head to the dining room.
In the dining room, CaptainSparklez informs everyone about TorqueDawg's death, and Jesse may show the cause of death. Jesse can then ask the others about TorqueDawg. CaptainSparklez reveals that TorqueDawg was searching for a "rare item" - the enchanted flint and steel. Jesse may or may not show the flint and steel, and CaptainSparklez informs everyone that they were brought here because someone has it. Suddenly, CaptainSparklez falls into a pit and dies from suffocation. The lights go out, and a figure with a white pumpkin on its head appears, declaring he will not rest until he gets the enchanted flint and steel, even if it means murder. Cassie Rose tries to escape, but the mansion is surrounded by zombies. Jesse and Lukas inspect the dining room, finding four buttons and realizing the White Pumpkin was a diversion using an armor stand and jukebox.
Jesse interrogates four suspects: DanTDM, LDShadowLady, Stampy Cat, and Lukas. Each has different stories about their knowledge and motives regarding the flint and steel. DanTDM claims it's his and has never seen tipped arrows before, going to Lizzie for potions and Stampy for redstone help. LDShadowLady wants the flint and steel, is an intermediate redstoner, and knows about tipped arrows, thinking Stampy could steal it and going to him for potion/redstone help. Stampy doesn't want the flint and steel, claims DanTDM made up his claim, and never saw tipped arrows, lying about being a redstone novice despite being the Tri-Block Champion. Jesse may accuse someone or conclude there isn't enough evidence. Lukas keeps an eye on everyone while Jesse, Petra, and Ivor inspect the kitchen trap.
In the kitchen, Jesse discovers a secret passageway behind a painting, controlled by a lever. The passageway leads to the library filled with spiders. Depending on the choice, either DanTDM or LDShadowLady are killed by spiders or the White Pumpkin. Jesse and Lukas chase the White Pumpkin to the east side, where he puts the mask on Lukas. Lukas is mistakenly accused but is later proven innocent as Jesse and Petra find evidence in the mansion's basement.
In the basement, they find an item transportation system, a white pumpkin farm, and a central hub containing potion information and inventories of the deceased. Dozens of calico cats lead Jesse to conclude that Cassie Rose is the White Pumpkin. Cassie confesses but falls into her own trap. The group thinks she is dead and leaves the mansion. They light a portal, but it is a dud, causing them to fall into a pit with endermites. The White Pumpkin (Cassie Rose) isn't dead and starts up the trap. Jesse and the White Pumpkin battle, with Jesse finally getting the upper hand and knocking her into her own trap. The player can choose to throw down Winslow or walk away, and the new Order of the Stone leaves through the real portal.
In a post-episode scene, a revived CaptainSparklez informs the player of the group's next adventure.